Skip to main content

A Tale of Two Malbecs

In January, the Argentine peso plunged 20% in value and citizens lined up to trade pesos for the American dollar. One result is, there has never been a better time for American consumers to buy Malbec.

Last week, I reviewed the 2011 Mendoza Vineyards Fairhills 1907 Malbec, which I really liked and rated at a score of 90 points.  This was an exceptional value for a wine costing $7.99 at Costco.

Today, we review the 2012 Piedra Negra Malbec Alta Coleccion from Mendoza.  This 100% Malbec wine is grown in semi desert conditions in the foothills of the Andes.  It was mechanically harvested and aged 5 to 6 months.  It has an A.C. of 13.5%.  It has some taste of ripe fruit and hints of pepper.

My opinion is that the wine lacks complexity and flavor and I was disappointed.  Costco says this wine is regularly $12.99 but currently it is reduced to $9.99.  I have researched the wine online and it is usually sold for less than $12.99, often at $9.99.  This is not the usual Costco good deal!

Skip the Piedra Negra Malbec and buy the Fairhills 1907 Malbec instead, or pay a little more and buy the Norton Reserva Malbec!

SC Wine Joe Rating for Piedra Malbec=86

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ken Wright Cellars Pinot Noir Willamette Valley 2018

 I was aware of the reputation of Ken Wright Cellars for Willamette Valley Pinot Noir but had never tried one of their wines.  The winery is most known for single vineyard Pinot Noirs but their entry level wine is a blend from several vineyards.  When I have looked for wine from Ken Wright, I have either found the single vineyard wines costing more than $60 or I have found the entry level Willamette Valley blend priced significantly higher than the $22 price on the winery website.  One well known wine shop in downtown Greenville actually sells it for $34.  I guess that the wine must be really good to command higher than retail prices. Two things have recently happened.  Costco has a Ken Wright premium Pinot Noir for around $40 and Whole Foods Market has the entry level Willamette Valley Pinot Noir on sale for $22 rather than their usual price of $27.  I chose the entry level Willamette Valley Pinot Noir and I am sure glad that I did. Ken Wright Willame...
3 comments
Read more

Dragon Vine, a novel by Steven Laine

It has been a year since I have posted to the South Carolina Wine Blog.  However, I was provided with an advance copy of the latest novel by Steven Laine entitled Dragon Vine   for my review.  Mr. Laine writes novels with a wine focused theme and I reviewed Mr. Laine's previous novel Root Cause  in 2019, which I greatly enjoyed. The synopsis of Dragon Vine is as follows: When his father dies in a wildfire, Carmine Cooper takes over the family winery in the middle of harvest, putting his dreams of becoming an architect on hold. He soon finds himself fighting with a vengeful neighbor, blackmailed by a local gang, harassed by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) authorities, and the target of an ATF (Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms & Explosives) investigation. Carmine’s only hope to solve his problems and finish his first solo vintage successfully rests in identifying an unknown grape variety his father grew and made into wine for a quarter century wit...
Post a Comment
Read more

Parcelica Grande 2018

 It has been a little over 3 months since I last posted on this blog.  I have taken that time to enjoy old favorites as well as wines bought directly from wineries.   I needed a break from trying a lot of unfamiliar wines so that I might have something new to write about.   However, now I am planning a live video post for the OlliLife newsletter at the Osher Lifelong Learning Institute at Furman University about value wines from lesser known wine regions and this will require Wine Jane and I to do a lot of research.  Well, someone has to do it! There are few places that have as much affordable quality wine as Spain.  The best known wines from Spain come from areas like Rioja in the northern part of Spain.  However, even greater values can be found further south in the areas bordering the Mediterranean Sea.  One such area is Yecla, about 50 miles inland from the sea.  In the past seven years, I have posted about four wines from Yeccl...
Post a Comment
Read more